Edgar Mendonca

Research / Tube crushing

Lateral compression of thin-walled tubes

Ring compression of aluminium 6063 tubes between flat plates: yield stress, elastic modulus and hardening modulus from one quasi-static test, checked against the Reid–Reddy theory.

Period
Mar 2022 – May 2023
Material
Aluminium 6063 tube, 50 × 50 × 1.6 mm
Loading
Quasi-static, 4 mm/min
Tools
MATLAB, Abaqus CAE

01Overview

Thin-walled tubes are used as energy absorbers in vehicles, aircraft and structures. In the ring (lateral) compression test a tube lies on its side between two rigid flat plates and is squashed across its diameter. Seen along the load, it takes a saddle shape. The test is simple, and its load–deflection curve carries enough information to back out the material's yield stress, elastic modulus and strain hardening.

This was part of a wider study of aluminium tube deformation and impact energy absorption, with experiments, analytical models and finite-element models compared side by side.

Lateral compression of a tube between two plates
Fig. 1Lateral compression of a tube between two plates
Finite-element models of tube crushing
Fig. 2Finite-element models of tube crushing

02Load–deflection response

The curve has three phases:

  • Elastic: load rises linearly and the tube springs back if unloaded.
  • Yield: plastic hinges form and the load levels off at the collapse load .
  • Hardening: the slope rises again as the material strain-hardens and the geometry stiffens.
Ideal load–displacement response of the ring compression test
Fig. 3Ideal load–displacement response of the ring compression test
The elastic and yield region in detail
Fig. 4The elastic and yield region in detail

03Experiment

An aluminium 6063 tube, 50 mm long, 50 mm in diameter and 1.6 mm thick, was compressed at a constant 4 mm/min. The load–displacement record was taken together with photographs of each stage of the collapse. The collapse load, read where the tangents to the elastic and plastic parts meet, was 0.94 kN.

Stages of the tube collapsing under lateral compression
Fig. 5Stages of the tube collapsing under lateral compression

04Properties from the test

Yield stress from the limit load (with for short rings, , and for long tubes, ), and elastic modulus from the elastic load and deflection (DeRuntz and Hodge; in plane stress, in plane strain):

With kN, kN, mm, mm, mm and mm:

Yield stress
183.6 MPa
Young's modulus
≈ 68 GPa
Hardening modulus
1.08 GPa

05Theory and fit

Reid and Reddy describe the hardening response with one non-dimensional parameter, which sets the shape of the load–deflection curve:

The test curve is made non-dimensional (load over collapse load, , against deflection over radius, ) and laid over the theoretical curves for a range of . The best fit was , which gives the average hardening modulus:

Theoretical non-dimensional load–deflection curves for several mR
Fig. 6Theoretical non-dimensional load–deflection curves for several mR
Experiment against theory: best fit at mR = 4
Fig. 7Experiment against theory: best fit at mR = 4

The code that draws the theoretical curves and fits them to a test record is on GitHub.

06References

  1. Reid, S. R., and Reddy, T. Y. (1978). Effect of strain hardening on the lateral compression of tubes between rigid plates. International Journal of Solids and Structures.
  2. Reddy, T. Y., and Reid, S. R. (1979). Lateral compression of tubes and tube-systems with side constraints. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences.
  3. Reddy, T. Y., and Reid, S. R. (1979). On obtaining material properties from the ring compression test. Nuclear Engineering and Design.